Franklin’s Notes for Replying to Two Letters from
Ralph Izard
AD: American Philosophical Society
[On or after February 1, 1778]
The terrible Ideas form'd of the Mellasses Article as express'd |
| express'd by Mr. Arthur Lee |
| Preamble proposes the Principle of Reciprocity |
| Ministers proposed that on our side Tobacco should not be |
| Mr. Lee objected to this on Behalf of the Tobacco Colonies. |
| I propos'd the General Clause |
| As affecting the Colonies more equally so less liable to Ob- |
| As I have always been against such Duties and think them |
| Yet I offer'd to join. Mr. Lee agreed to this. |
| But finding that such terrible Ideas— |
| I was willing to strike both out |
| Answer Mr. Iz.'s Arguments |
French may lay Duties on their European Exports—no Check |
Can we not then lay Duties on their Imports? |
Not the least Probability. Interfere with Brandy. |
| If they wish us to take their Brandy may it not be their Interest |
to discourage our making Rum? Why might they not chuse |
to have that Manufacture themselves? And sell us the Rum |
instead of the Mellasses; they may indeed yet do it. |
| Contrary to the Principles of the Treaty, Instructions, &c. |
Personals.
2d Letter—Extraordinary Inattention. |
| The only Gentleman I have visited for 50 Years |
| Poor Understanding was the favourable Construction. |
| Thanks for his Endeavours |
| Did not expect that having prevailed on that Gentle- |
man to be more reasonable he would have taken |
| Exacted Respect of no Value |
| Respect a voluntary Thing |
629105 = 025-559b.html