Pennsylvania Assembly Committee: Report on the Western Bounds
Printed in Votes and Proceedings of the House of Representatives, 1753-1754 (Philadelphia, 1754), pp. 38-9.
[March 7, 1754]

Having carefully considered the several Testimonies, Computations, Maps and Draughts, laid before us, relating to the Western Bounds of this Province, we do report,

That it appears to your Committee, by the Testimony of Richard Peters, Secretary of this Province, and Nicholas Scull, Surveyor-General, that the Temporary Line was run in 1739, by B. Eastburn, then Surveyor-General, and other Surveyors, on Oath, to the Kittochtinny Hills, about three Miles West from Philip David’s Plantation, extending West from Philadelphia (as measured on the Surface) 144 Miles.

And that the said Richard Peters, Esq; doth aver, that he hath travelled from Aucquick to Philip David’s, and made diligent Observations and Enquiry, and that to the best of his Knowledge and Belief, the Place called The Three Springs, is rather Eastward of the Meridian of the End of the Temporary Line, and thirty Miles Northward of the End of said Line.

And that the several computed travelling Distances from the Three Springs to Ohio, laid before the Committee, are as follows, viz.

Miles.
150
145
Rays-town Road, to Shanopins, from said Springs, 148
And the Franks-town Road from Ditto, 151
from Ditto, 140
make about 147
To which, the Length of the Temporary Line, 144
being added, make 291
265
Which is short of the above Sum, Miles 26

That all the several Accounts, which speak of the Course of the Road, do agree, that it is very winding and crooked in many Places, to avoid Creeks and Swamps, and very uneven as it passes through a mountainous Country; and Pattin’s Map of the Road, laid before us, makes it in a straight Line from the Three Springs to Shanopins, but Eighty-three Miles; which Map, however, we do not understand to have been made from actual Mensurations; but by taking the Course from one known Mountain to another with a Compass, and computing the Distance by the common Methods of Estimation used by Travellers on Horse-back.

Andrew Montour and John Pattin say, that the Road is very crooked, and that having, by the Governor’s Directions (to said Pattin) observed the Courses and Distances with all the Exactness in their Power, it cannot, in their Judgment, on a straight Line, exceed Eighty-five Miles.

By which Estimation Sixty-two of the travelled Miles are lost in the Crooks between the Three Springs and Shanopins.

William West saith likewise, that the Road is very crooked, and that in several Places travelling many Miles produces but a few Miles Westing; particularly between the Shawana Cabins and Kekinnypalins, computed near thirty Miles, he thinks would not make more than ten Miles Westing.

William West farther saith, That an Observation was made of the Latitude of Shanopins Town by Colonel Fry, who found it to be in 40. 26. which is about Forty-one Miles North of the Temporary Line.

Upon the Premises, your Committee would observe,

1. That the computed Miles are, as estimated by Travellers, who judge only from the Time taken up in Travelling, and have never been measured; and that the Miles so computed on the Road from the Three Springs to Shanopins, added to the measured Length of the Temporary Line, make Twenty-six Miles more than the Mathematicians say there are in five Degrees of Longitude at Lat. 40.

2. That the Temporary Line was measured on the Surface of the Earth, up Hills and down Valleys, and therefore, an horizontal Line of one Hundred and Forty-four Miles must extend farther Westward; but how much, your Committee cannot take upon them to say.

3. That the travelled Line from the Three Springs to Shanopins is not only up Hill and down, through a more mountainous Country, but is agreed by all to deviate much from a straight Line to the Right and Left; and therefore, when drawn out to a horizontal Line, must extend yet farther Westward, in Proportion, than the Temporary Line.

Whether these Irregularities of both Lines, taken all together, will not exceed the Difference of Twenty-six Miles, must be submitted to the Judgment of the House.

And if, upon the Whole, Shanopins-town be judged within the Limits of the Royal Grant to our Proprietary, Weningo, which by the Testimony of Andrew Montour, lies N. E. of Shanopins, and North of Lawrel-hill, must be deemed more so; since the Distance from Lawrel-hill, on a straight Line to Shanopins, does not by his, and Pattin’s Account, exceed Thirty-four Miles.

And accordingly we find that the French Map, by M. Bellin, lays down the whole Riviere au Beuff (which runs into Ohio at Weningo) and on which the French Forts are built, but about four Degrees of Longitude West from Philadelphia.

All which is humbly submitted to the Correction of the House, this seventh Day of March, 1754, by

Joseph Fox, Peter Worall,
Benjamin Franklin, Joseph Armstrong,
Mahlon Kirkbride, Moses Starr.
George Ashbridge,
623168 = 005-222a.html