Remarks on Thomas Penn’s Estimate of the Province
Printed in [Richard Jackson], An Historical Review of the Constitution and Government of Pensylvania ... London: Printed for R. Griffiths, in Paternoster-Row, 1759, pp. 431-8.

The Proprietaries have for a long Series of Years made a great Secret of the Value of their Estate and Revenue: By Accident the following authentic Paper is fallen into our Hands, and will serve as a Groundwork, on which the Reader may be enabled to form some Idea of the Value of that Estate in Pensylvania. It is a Copy of an original Paper drawn by Mr. Thomas Penn himself many Years ago, and endors’d “My Estimate of the Province, T Penn.”

Estimate.
Pensylvania Curr.
“1 Lands granted since my Arrival are very
near 270,000 Acres, of which not 10,000
£ 41,850 0 0
have been paid for; more than of old
Grants are remaining unpaid; is
“2 The Rent on the said Grants is £550
Sterling a Year, which at 20 Years Pur- 18,150 0 0
chase, and 165 per Cent. Exchange, is
“3 The old Rent, £420 a Year Sterling, at
15,246 0 0
ditto, is
“4 Lands granted between Roll and the
first Article are £570 a Year Sterling, 18,810 0 0
which at 20 Years Purchase, and 165 per
Cent. is
“5 To the Difference between £420 and
£570 for Arrearages of Rents which may
be computed at half the Time of the other 2,722 10 0
Arrearages, that is 11 Years at 165 per
Cent.
“6 Ferries let on short Leases, the Rents
1,000 0 0
being £40 a Year are worth
“7 Lands settled in the Province for which
no Grants are yet passed, except a few
since the above Account was taken, not 63,000 0 0
less than 400,000 Acres, which at £15 10s.
0d. amounts to
“The Rent at an Half-penny an Acre is £833
27,500 0 0
6s. 8d. a Year Sterling, reckon'd as above is
£ 188,278 10 0
“Manors.
M. from per
the City, Acres, H.
1 Conestogoe, 65 13,400 at £40 5,360 0 0
2 Gilbert's, 25 3,200 70 2,240 0 0
3 Springfield, 12 1,600 75 1,200 0 0
4 Highlands, 35 2,500 30 750 0 0
5 Spring-tow[n], 37 10,000 35 3,500 0 0
6 Vincent's, 40 20,000 35 7,000 0 0
7 Richland's, 35 10,000 15 1,500 0 0
9 About 20 Tracts in the several Counties,
mostly 500 Acres each; reckon'd 10,000 4,000 0 0
at £40
Springet's-bury 207 Acres at £5 1,035 0 0
On the North Side of
“ 8 the Town 50 30 1,500 0 0
Back of the said Land 15 10 150 0 0
“ 9 Lot in the Bank at the North End of
600 0 0
the Town, 200 Feet at £3
“10 A Front and Bank Lot between Vine
612 0 0
and Sassafras Street, 102 Feet at £6
“11 Bank Lot between
612 0 0
Cedar and Pine Street, 204 Feet at £3
“12 Front Lot on the Side
of Cedar Street 102 3 306 0 0
“13 Ditto between Cedar
and Pine Street 160 2 320 0 0
“14 Bank Lot between
the same Streets 40 2 80 0 0
“15 Marsh Land near
the Town 600 Acres at £3 1,800 0 0
“16 Ditto 200 Acres, at 1s. Sterling Rent,
330 0 0
and 165 per Cent. is
“Lands within the Draft of the Town,
at least 500 Acres.
“250 nearest Delaware, at £15 per
3,750 0 0
Acre
“250 nearest Schuylkill, at £10 per
2,500 0 0
Acre
“17 Omitted.—Streiper's Tract in Bucks
1,250 0 0
County, 35 Miles; 5,000 Acres at £25
“18 The Rents of the above Manors and
Lands being 77,072 Acres at a Half-pen-
5,298 12 0
ny per Acre. 20 Years Purchase, and 165
per Cent. Exchange, is
£233,972 2 0
“The Government to be calculated at no less
than was to have been paid for it, viz. 18,150 0 0
£11,000 at 165 per Cent. is
£252,122 2 0
“In this Calculation no Notice is taken of the
Thirds reserved on the Bank Lots (a Copy of
the Patents J. Penn has by him to shew the
Nature of them) and nine Tenths of the
Province remains undisposed of.
“Three Fifths of all Royal Mines is reserved in
the Grants, and in all Grants since the Year
1732. One fifth Part of all other Mines, de-
livered at the Pits Mouth without Charge is
also reserved.
“No Value is put on the Proprietor's Right to
escheated Lands; and, besides these Advan-
tages, several Offices are in the Proprietor's
Gift of considerable Value.
“Register General, about £200
“Naval Officer, £300
“Clerk of Philadelphia, £400
Chester, £300
Bucks, £200
Lancaster, £200
“Besides several other Offices of less Value.
These are only guessed at."

The above Paper has no Date, but by sundry Circumstances in it, particularly there being no Value put on the Thirds of the Bank Lots, because they were not then fallen in; and by the Valuation put on the Lands (which is very different from their present Value) it must have been drawn while Mr. Thomas Penn resided in Pensylvania, and probably more than Twenty Years ago; Since which Time a vast Addition has been made to the Value of the Reserved Lands, and a great Quantity of Land has been disposed of, perhaps equal to all preceding. We must therefore add to the above Sum of £252,122 2s. 0d. the following Articles, viz.

Pensylvania Curr.
Brought over £252,122 2 0
1. For the increased Value of the Lands of the
Conestogoe Manor now valued at £400
per Hundred Acres, and in the above Esti- 48,240 0 0
mate valued only at £40 per Hundred, the
said increased Value being £360 per Hun-
dred, on 13,400 Acres,
2. For the increased Value of Gilbert's Manor,
10,560 0 0
now worth £400 per Hundred Acres,
3. For Ditto on Springfield Manor, now worth
6,800 0 0
£500 per Hundred Acres,
4. For Ditto on Highland's Manor, now worth
8,000 0 0
£350 per Hundred Acres,
5. For Ditto on Springtown, now worth £400
36,500 0 0
per Hundred Acres,
6. For Ditto on Vincent's Manor, now worth
53,000 0 0
£300 per Hundred Acres,
7. For Ditto on Richland's now worth £450
43,500 0 0
per Hundred Acres,
9. For Ditto on the 20 Tracts, now worth £300
26,000 0 0
per Hundred Acres,
8. For Ditto on Springetsbury, &c. at least 2,685 0 0
9. For Ditto on all the Articles of Lots from No.
5,060 0 0
9 to 14. being trebled in Value,
15. For Ditto on the Marsh Land, now worth
10,200 0 0
£20 per Acre,
16. For Ditto on the Value of Lands within the
Draft of the Town, now worth one with 18,750 0 0
another, £50 per Acre,
17. For Ditto on Streiper's Tract now worth
15,000 0 0
£325 per Hundred.
[On the next Articles for the Reserved Rent,
and the Value of the Government, we add no
Advance.]
For the Thirds of the Bank Lots and Improvements
on them, as they fell in after this
Estimate was made; reckoning every 20
37,280 0 0
Feet of Ground with its Improvements,
one with another, worth £480 the Thirds
being £160 for each 20 Feet,
573,697 0 0
Thus far for the present Value of what was then
estimated, But since that Time, very great
Quantities of Land have been sold, and
several new Manors laid out and reserv'd;
one of which, viz. that of Conedoguinet is
said to contain 30,000 Acres: The Quantity
sold since the Estimate, must be at least
equal to what was sold before, as the
People are doubled, and the Manors prob-
ably equal in Quantity: We may therefore
suppose, that a fair Estimate of the Lands
sold, Rents and Manors reserved, and new
Towns laid out into Lots, since the above
Estimate, would be at least equal to it, that
is another Tenth, and amount also to
£573,697 2s. 0d.
573,697 2 0
For Eight of these Nine Tenths of the Province
which were not dispos'd of at the Time of
making the Estimate; Note, The Province
Grant to William Penn is of three Degrees
of Latitude, and five of Longitude; each
Degree of Latitude contains 69½ Statute
Miles, and each Degree of Longitude
about Lat. 40 contains 53 Statute Miles;
so the Dimensions of the Province are 265
Miles by 208½, which gives for its Con-
tents 55,252½ square Miles or Thirty five
Millions, Three Hundred and Sixty-one
Thousand, Six Hundred Acres; Eight Tenths
of this Quantity, is 28,289,280 Acres, which
at £15 10s. per 100 Acres (the present
selling Price) is
4,384,838 8 0
For the yearly Quitrent on 28,289,280 Acres at a
Halfpenny Sterling per Acre, is £58,936
per Annum, which at 165 per Cent. and 20
Years Purchase, is
1,856,484 0 0
For the additional Value on One Tenth Part, at
least, of those Eight Tenths, which being
pick'd out of the best of the Lands after
every Purchase from the Indians, before
any private Person is allowed to take up
any, and kept for 20 or 30 Years, is to be
sold at a Medium for £300 per 100 Acres
Advance; this on 2,828,928 Acres, is
8,486,784 0 0
For the Three Fifths of all Royal Mines, and One
Fifth of all other Mines reserv'd to these
Lords Proprietors, we can as yet estimate
no Sum, and must leave it a Blank as we
find it; but since in the Ridges of Moun-
tains not yet settled, some very valuable
Specimens of Ores have been found by
Travellers, it is not unlikely this Article
may in Time become considerable beyond
Computation.
For the Offices we shall likewise make no Estimation,
tho' they are greatly increas'd in
Number and Value, with the Increase of
People; as we believe the Proprietaries do
not raise immediate Money from the Grants
of those Offices at present, they being
chiefly dispos'd of to bribe or reward their
Partisans and Favourites; in which how-
ever they may find their Account.
For the Escheats we likewise add nothing; for
tho' it is thought a valuable Article, we
have no Information on which we can
form any Judgment concerning its Value,
it must however be continually increasing.
There is another Article, we are greatly at a Loss
about, which is the Interest of Money aris-
ing to the Proprietors from Securities on
Lands possess'd by Persons unable to make
present Payment. These pay not only
Quitrent for the Land but Interest for the
Purchase Money. This Interest is thought
to be a very considerable Income, but we
cannot estimate it.
The Three Lower Counties on Delaware, which
are a distinct Territory and Government
from the Province of Pensylvania, and
held by a different Title, are also a very
valuable Part of the Proprietary Estate;
tho' what Value should be put on the same
is at present difficult to say.
Total in Pensylvania Currency £15,875,500 12 0
In Sterling, about Ten Millions!

But on the whole, it appears pretty clearly, that deducting all the Articles containing the Valuation of Lands yet unsold, and unappropriated within their Patent, and the Manors and Rents to be hereafter reserv’d, and allowing for any small over-Valuations in their present reserv’d Lands and Incomes [tho’ ’tis thought if any be it will not be found to exceed the under-Valuation in other Instances] there cannot remain less than a Million of Property which they now at this Time have in Pensylvania.

And in that Province there are but 20,000 Families, to each of which, one with another, there does not belong more than £300 of Property, if so much; which multiply’d by 20,000 gives £6,000,000 for the whole Property of the People there.

The Proprietaries then have in present Possession a Property there at least equal to one sixth of That of the People. They ought therefore to pay the same Proportion of the Taxes.

That the Reader may form some Judgment of the Profits made by this Monopoly of Land in America in Favour of the House of Penn, we shall just mention, that the Land is first purchased of the Indians, and none but the Proprietors are allow’d to purchase of the Indians within the Limits of their Grant: The Indians of late Years have somewhat rais’d their Price; and for the last great Purchase in 1754, which was of about Seven Millions of Acres, they demanded (how much do you think?) no less than 2000 Dollars amount at Seven and Sixpence Currency each, to Seven Hundred and Fifty Pounds.

Pensyl. Currency.
The Land so bought the Proprietor has the
Moderation to sell (except the best of it
serv'd in Manors for himself) at so low a
Price as £15 10s. 0d. per Hundred Acres,
which will produce
£1,085,000 0 0
Deduct the Purchase Money 750 0 0
                  Remains Profit £1,084,250 0 0
Besides the Profit of a Tenth of the 7,000,000
Acres, reserv'd in Manors to be sold here-
after at an Advance of at least £300 per
Hundred Acres
2,100,000 0 0
And also the Quitrent to be reserv'd on
7,000,000 Acres at ½d. Sterling per Acre
£14,583 6s 8d. which at 165 per Cent. and
20 Years Purchase, is worth            
£481,250 0 0
Profit, in all £3,665,500 0 0

But the Indian Council at Onondago not being satisfied with the sale of so much Land at once, the Proprietors have since been obliged to disgorge a Part of the Hunting Country they had not paid for, and reconvey the same to the Indians, who, when they are dispos’d to sell it, may possibly demand 2000 Dollars more, for which the above Account must then have Credit.

One would think that where such good Bargains are bought of the poor Natives, there should be no Occasion for fraudulent Art to over-reach them, in order to take more than is granted: And that if a War occasion’d by such Injuries should be drawn upon the innocent Inhabitants, those who were the Cause of the War, if they did not, as in Justice they ought, bear the whole Expence of it, at lest they would not refuse to bear a reasonable Part. Whether this has ever been the Case is now a Subject of Publick Enquiry.

But let us see how the Land bought in such lumping Pennyworths of the Natives by the Monopolist, is huckster’d out again to the King’s Subjects. To give the Reader some Idea of this, after remarking that £15 10s. 0d. per Hundred Acres for wild Land, is three Times dearer than the Proprietor of Maryland’s Price, and ten Times dearer than his Majesty’s Lands in Virginia and Carolina, both as good if not better Countries, we shall present him with a genuine Account, stated under the Hand of the Proprietor’s Receiver General, obtain’d with great Difficulty by the Purchaser of two Tracts of Land, some Time after he had paid his Money; when on more particular Consideration of the Sum paid compar’d with the Quantity bought, he imagin’d he had paid too much. The Account is as follows, viz.

John Fisher in Right of Jacob Job Dr.
“To Land 423 A. 53 Ps. in Pextang Township,
Lancaster County, granted to said Job by War-
rant of Mar. 19th, 1742
£65 12 1
“Interest from 1st March 1732 to 19th March 1742,
is 10 Years 18 Days 39 11 2
105 3 3
                 “19th March 1742, paid 15
90 3 3
“Int. from 19th March 1742 to 20th February 1747,
is 4 Years, 11 Months, 1 Day 26 11 11
“Quitr. to next Month is 15 Years, £13 4s. 7d. Sterl.
at 85 per Cent. 24 9 6
141 4 8
John Fisher in Right of Thomas Cooper Dr.
“To Land 268 Acres in Pextang Township, Lancaster
County granted by Warrant of 9th January
1743 to said Cooper
£41 10 9
“Interest from 1st March 1737 to 9th January 1743
is 5 Years, 10 Months, 8 Days 14 11 9
56 2 6
                 “9th January 1743 paid 7 10 0
48 12 6
“Interest from 9th January 1743 to 20th February
11 19 10
1747 is 4 Years, 1 Month, 11 Days
“Quitr. to next Month is 10 Years, £5 11s. 8d. Sterl.
10 6 7
at 85 per Cent.
70 18 11
£141 4 8 20th February 1747.
70 18 11
212 3 7
10 Transfer, &c.
212 13 7
Philadelphia, 23d February 1747.

“Received of John Fisher Two Hundred and Twelve Pounds, Three Shillings and Seven Pence, in full for 423 Acres in Pextang Township, granted by Warrant of 19th March 1742, to Jacob Job, and for 268 Acres in same Township, by Warrant of 9th January 1743 to Thomas Cooper, both in the County of Lancaster.

£212 3 7
For the Hon. Proprietaries,
10 Fees
(    )
212 13 7

Lynford Lardner Receiver Gen.

n. b. The Quitrent in full to 1st March 1747.

The Purchaser not being skill’d in Accounts, but amaz’d at the Sum, apply’d to a Friend to examine this Account, who stated it over again as follows, viz.

John Fisher in the Right of Jacob Job, Dr.
1742. “To 423 Acres, 50 Per. of Land, in Pex-
19th tang, County Lancaster, granted to said
March. Job by Warrant dated this Day
£65 12 1
“By Cash paid that Day 15 0 0
£50 12 1
“To interest on £50 12s. 1d. from the
19th March 1742 to 20th Feb. 1747,
being 4y. 11 m. 1d.
14 18 9
“To 5 Years Quitrent for said Land at One
Halfpenny Sterl. per Acre Ann. viz.
from March 1742, the Time the Land
was surveyed (for Quitrent ought not to
be paid before) to March 1747 amount-
ing in the whole to £4 8s. 4d. Sterling
at 85 per Cent. the Exchange charg'd in
the Account delivered
8 5 9
“20th Feb. 1747. Sum due on Job's Right £73 16 7
John Fisher, in Right of Thomas Cooper. Dr.
1743. “To 268 Acres of Land in Pextang afore-
9th said, granted said Cooper by Warrant
January, this day
£41 10 9
“By Cash paid that Day 7 10
“9th Jan. 1743, Ballance due £34 0 9
“To Interest on £34 0s. 9d. from 9th Jan.
1743, to 20th Feb. 1747 being 4 y. 1 m. 8 7 8
11d.
“To 4 Years and 2 Months Quitrent for
said Lands, viz. from Jan. 1743 to the
First March 1747, Amounting in the
whole to £2 6s. 6d. Sterling, at 85 per
Cent
4 7 2 ¼
“20th Feb. 1747. Sum due on Cooper's
Right £46 15 7 ¼

“In Feb. 1747, John Fisher obtained a Proprietary Patent for the Lands above mentioned. But by the Accompts then exhibited to him, and which he paid, he was charged on Job’s Right £141 4s. 8d. which is £67 8s. 1d. more than the above Account, and also was charged on Coopers Right, £70 18s. 11d, which is £24 3s. 3¾d. more than the above Accompt of Cooper’s. So that by the two Accompts it is supposed he has paid £91 11s. 4¾d. more than could legally be received from him.

“The Reason of such great Difference in the Accompts are as follow, viz.

“1st That Interest has been charged on the Consideration Money for Job’s Land, for 10 Years and 18 Days before the Land was survey’d.

“2d That Quitrent has also been charged for that Time at 85 per Cent.

“3d That the Principle and Interest to the Time of Warrant and Survey were added together, and that Interest was charged for that Total to the Time the Patent was granted.

“4th That Interest has been charged on the Consideration Money for Cooper’s Land, for 5y. 10m. 8d. before the Land was survey’d.

“5th That Quitrent has also been charged for that Time at 85 per Cent.

“6th That the Principle and Interest to the Time of Warrant and Survey were added, and Interest charged for that Total to the Time the Patent was granted, which is compound Interest.”

To these Remarks of the Accountant we shall only add, That the Price of Exchange between Philadelphia and London is not fix’d, but rises and falls according to the Demand for Bills; That 85 per Cent. charg’d for the Exchange in this Account is the highest Exchange that perhaps was ever given in Pensylvania, occasion’d by some particular Scarcity of Bills at a particular Time; That the Proprietor himself in his Estimate reckons the Exchange but at 65, which is indeed near the Medium, and this Charge is 20 per Cent. above it. That the Valuing the Currency of the Country according to the casual Rate of Exchange with London, is in itself a false Valuation, the Currency not being really depreciated in Proportion to an occasional Rise of Exchange; since every Necessary of Life is to be purchas’d in the Country, and every Article of Expence defray’d by that Currency (English Goods only excepted) at as low Rates after as before such Rise of Exchange; That therefore the Proprietor’s obliging those who purchase of him to pay their Rents according to the Rate of Exchange is unjust, the Rate of Exchange including withal the Risque and Freight on remitting Money to England; and is besides a dangerous Practice, as the great Sums to be yearly remitted to him, put it in the Power of his own Agents to play Tricks with the Exchange at Pleasure, raise it at the Time of Year when they are to receive the Rents, by buying a few Bills at a high Price, and afterwards lower it by refraining to buy till they are sold more reasonably.

By this Account of the Receiver General’s, it appears we have omitted two other Articles in the Estimation of the Proprietary Estate, viz.

For the Quitrents of Lands many Years before they are
----
granted!
For the Interest of the Purchase-Money many Years before
----
the Purchases are made!

On what Pretence these Articles of Charge are founded, how far they may be extended, and what they may amount to, is beyond our Knowledge; we are therefore obliged to leave them blank till we can obtain more particular Information.

623787 = 008-360a.html